The Two Faces of Islam The West vs. The Islamic World Introduction After the September 11, 2001 attacks , President George W. Bush made a statement declaring that "Islam is a religion of peace" and that Allah was not pleased with the terrorists. While this message was meant to reassure American Muslims and prevent Islamophobia , it also highlighted the stark contrast between Islam in the West and Islam in the Islamic world. This divide is often downplayed or ignored in mainstream discourse. However, it is crucial to examine the two Islams —the "peaceful" Islam preached in the West and the strict, traditional Islam practiced in Islamic-controlled countries. This article will explore the fundamental differences between these two versions of Islam and how they shape global politics, religious freedom, and cultural identity. 1. The Two Islams: A Fundamental Divide There is a clear dis...
Posts
Showing posts from October, 2025
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Can a Devout Muslim Be a Loyal American Citizen? Introduction The question of whether a devout Muslim can be a loyal American patriot is a contentious one, often discussed in political, theological, and legal circles. While many Muslims in the U.S. proudly serve in the military, law enforcement, and civic roles , the fundamental principles of Islam and Western democracy appear to be in conflict at a deeper level. This article examines the key contradictions between devout Islamic beliefs and American constitutional values , analyzing the theological, legal, and political challenges that arise. 1. Theological Conflicts Between Islam and American Values A devout Muslim's primary allegiance is to Allah and the Quran , which dictates Sharia law as the ultimate legal and moral authority. This creates a fundamental contradiction between Islam and the secular democratic framework of the United...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Did Muhammad Plant the Seeds of Terrorism in Islam? A Historical Analysis Introduction The role of Muhammad in shaping Islamic teachings on warfare, violence, and governance has been debated for centuries. Some argue that he set a precedent for religious violence, while others contend that his actions were defensive and in response to persecution. This article examines whether Muhammad's teachings and actions contributed to the foundation of Islamic terrorism by exploring historical accounts, Islamic scriptures, and modern implications. 1. The Early Meccan Period: A Preacher of Peace? Passive Resistance and Persecution (610-622 CE) Muhammad’s early years in Mecca were marked by peaceful preaching and no recorded acts of violence . He and his followers faced persecution from the Quraysh, prompting some to flee to Abyssinia. No military actions or self-defense efforts were undertaken during this period. Key Verse: "There is no compulsion in reli...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
The Pact of Umar The Foundation of Dhimmi Status and Its Modern Implications Introduction The Pact of Umar is a historical document that set the legal foundation for the treatment of non-Muslims under Islamic rule , specifically Jews and Christians (dhimmis) . It dictated their inferior legal and social status in Muslim-majority societies in exchange for protection, provided they paid the jizya tax and adhered to strict regulations. This second-class status persisted throughout history and continues to influence modern Islamic governance in some regions. This article examines the historical origins, legal implications, and modern relevance of the Pact of Umar. 1. Historical Origins of the Pact of Umar The Pact of Umar is traditionally attributed to Caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab (ruled 634-644 AD) or Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz (ruled 717-720 AD) . However, historians believe it evolve...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Conclusion: Muhammad the Untouchable The Real Center of Islam Muhammad the Untouchable: Why Islam Depends More on Its Founder Than Its God has laid bare an inconvenient but inescapable truth: Islam is not built solely upon the worship of a transcendent God. It is structurally dependent on one man— Muhammad . The Cult of the Messenger Islam’s core creed, the Shahada , does not stop at affirming the oneness of God. It demands recognition of Muhammad’s exclusive authority as a non-negotiable condition for salvation (Schimmel, 1992). Deny God, and you're condemned; deny Muhammad, and you're damned—regardless of your belief in God. In mystical theology and popular tradition, Muhammad is elevated far beyond a mortal messenger. He is described as the first created being , the cosmic intercessor , and the “Perfect Man” ( al-Insān al-Kāmil )—roles that flirt with divinity itself (Chittick, 2000). Meanwhile, Islamic law enforces t...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Part 7: Muhammad as Intercessor and Cosmic Authority Series: Muhammad the Untouchable — Why Islam Depends More on Its Founder Than Its God How Muhammad Became More Than a Messenger — Almost a God Islam officially denies divine incarnation, incarnation of God in any form, and even the veneration of saints. Yet in practice, Muhammad has been elevated far beyond a mere prophet. Over centuries, Muslim belief and devotion have transformed him into a cosmic, semi-divine figure whose power and presence permeate Islamic spirituality, law, and eschatology. This post exposes how Muhammad evolved from messenger to untouchable intercessor and cosmic authority — effectively becoming Islam’s de facto deity . 1. The First Created Being and the Reason for Creation Mystical and theological texts in Islam, especially within Sufi traditions, depict Muhammad as: The first being created by God — existing before the universe itself. The “Light of Muhammad” ( Nur Muhammad ), from ...
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Part 6: The Hadith Eclipse the Qur’an Series: Muhammad the Untouchable — Why Islam Depends More on Its Founder Than Its God Why Muhammad’s Words, Not God’s, Shape Islamic Law and Practice Muslims insist the Qur’an is the literal, perfect, final word of God. Yet in practice, Islamic life, law, and doctrine are overwhelmingly derived from Hadith — collections of sayings, actions, and approvals attributed to Muhammad. This dynamic reveals a profound theological and legal truth: Islam is not governed by divine revelation alone — it is ruled by how later generations remembered, recorded, and sometimes fabricated Muhammad’s behavior. This post exposes the consequences of this fact: how Muhammad’s legacy overtakes God’s text, why Hadith are so problematic, and how this dynamic fatally undermines the claim that Islam is a pure divine religion. 1. What Are Hadith? The Hadith are reports describing what Muhammad said, did, or tacitly approved. They are se...