No Compulsion in Religion? 

The Abrogation Trap Inside the Qur’an

Islamic apologists love to quote:

“There is no compulsion in religion.” (Qur’an 2:256)

They claim it proves Islam is inherently tolerant. But there’s a fatal flaw: the doctrine of abrogation. And it exposes the entire Qur’an as a contradictory, incoherent text.

---

⚡ The Core Problem: Abrogation Cancels Itself

The Qur’an itself declares:

“We do not abrogate a verse or cause it to be forgotten, except that We bring forth one better than it or similar to it.” (Qur’an 2:106)

This idea — called naskh — says some verses cancel others. So, what’s the problem?

👉 If abrogation happened at all, the older, “abrogated” verses should be erased from the Qur’an.
👉 If no abrogation happened, why have generations of Islamic scholars (like Ibn Kathir, Al-Qurtubi, Al-Shafi’i) insisted it did?

Either way, the Qur’an looks like a legal contract full of obsolete clauses still printed as divine revelation. That’s not “eternal clarity” — it’s confusion.

---

🟥 The Contradictory “Peace” and “Violence” Commands

In its early Meccan period, the Qur’an says:

• “No compulsion in religion.” (2:256)

• “To you your religion, and to me mine.” (109:6)

But once Muhammad gained political power in Medina, the tone shifted:

• “Kill the polytheists wherever you find them.” (9:5)

• “Fight those who do not believe in Allah… until they pay the jizya and feel subdued.” (9:29)

Islamic scholars themselves admit: the peaceful verses were abrogated by the later militant ones. Ibn Kathir says 2:256 was overridden by 9:5. This is not a fringe view — it’s mainstream Sunni doctrine.

---

⚠️ The Logical Collapse

Here’s why it’s incoherent:

✅ If abrogation is real:

• The Qur’an cancels itself.

• It’s no longer a single, unified revelation — it’s a patchwork of temporary commands.

✅ If abrogation is false:

• All the violent commands still apply — forever.

Either way, Islam’s claim to be a final, clear, eternal word of God falls apart.

---

💡 The Final Incoherence: Unchanging Yet Changing?

Islam teaches the Qur’an is:

• Uncreated, eternal

• Perfect and final

Yet it also abrogates itself? How can an eternal word of God change? How can it cancel itself?

The answer is: it can’t. And the contradictions show that abrogation is not a divine principle — it’s a desperate attempt by later theologians to fix an inconsistent human book.

---

💥 Conclusion: A House of Cards

The closer you look, the clearer it gets:

• Islam’s “peaceful” verses were temporary.

• Abrogation is a theological band-aid for internal contradictions.

• The Qur’an’s so-called “eternal clarity” is just an illusion.

• Like a house of cards, the whole system collapses under its own contradictions.

So next time someone quotes “no compulsion in religion” as proof of Islam’s tolerance, remember:
➡️ That verse was cancelled by later commands for war and subjugation.
➡️ It’s not a sign of tolerance — it’s a sign of a man-made patchwork trying to cover up its own cracks.